Category Archives: Employment at will rule

Concerted activity, Employment at will rule, Harless wrongful discharge, National Labor Relations Act

When Personal Conduct Off the Clock Leads to Termination: Off-Duty Behavior and Employment Law

Leave a comment

Let’s talk about something that’s become more and more relevant in today’s world—off-duty conduct. What happens when an employee gets into trouble outside of work? Can an employer fire someone for something they did on their own time? And how do courts draw the line between private behavior and job-related consequences?

The short answer: yes, employers often can terminate someone for off-duty conduct, but it depends heavily on the circumstances—and there are key legal protections that limit this right.

This area of law lives in a gray zone where employment at-will, public policy, discrimination statutes, and even social media all overlap. Let’s dive in.

At-Will Employment and the Right to Terminate

As you know, West Virginia is an at-will employment state, like most of the country. That means employers can generally terminate an employee for any reason—or no reason at all—so long as it’s not illegal or in violation of a public policy. See W. Va. Code § 21-5-4 and Felix v. Grafton City Hospital, 447 S.E.2d 418 (W. Va. 1994).

So, in theory, an employer could fire an employee because of something they did off the clock—say, a bar fight, a controversial Facebook post, or a DUI arrest.

But theory and practice aren’t always the same.

Continue reading When Personal Conduct Off the Clock Leads to Termination: Off-Duty Behavior and Employment Law →
Employee handbook, Employment at will rule

The Role of Employee Handbooks in Employment Law

Leave a comment

Employee handbooks often get overlooked, but they play a crucial role in shaping workplace policies and protecting both employers and employees. A well-drafted handbook sets expectations, outlines rights and responsibilities, and can even serve as evidence in legal disputes. Let’s explore why every employer should have one and what employees need to know about them.

What Is an Employee Handbook?

An employee handbook is a document that provides guidelines on workplace policies, procedures, and expectations. While not legally required, a good handbook helps ensure compliance with labor laws and creates consistency in company practices.

Common sections in an employee handbook include:

  • Workplace conduct and expectations
  • Anti-discrimination and harassment policies
  • Wage and hour policies
  • Leave policies (FMLA, sick leave, vacation, etc.)
  • Disciplinary procedures and termination policies
  • Workplace safety rules
  • Confidentiality and data security policies

Are Employee Handbooks Legally Binding?

Continue reading The Role of Employee Handbooks in Employment Law →
Contract Issues, Employee handbook, Employment at will rule

Handbooks and other ways to bypass the employment at will rule

1 Comment

Part 2 of a series on West Virginia employment law

This article follows up my prior blog article, The Employment at Will Rule in West Virginia. In that article, I explained the basic contours of the employment at will rule.

With the employment at will rule radiating in the background, there are many ways it can be modified or bypassed. All claims relating to discrimination and retaliation, for example, modify the rule to the extent an exception is created by which the employer may not terminate the rule for a specific reason, such as age.

Scenarios: handbooks and other promises

But this article focuses on contractual or contract-like limitations on the employment at will rule. The parties (employer and employee) can enter into a formal employment contract that modifies the employment at will rule. But I am not addressing that formal contract in this article. I am really trying to focus on two scenarios:

Continue reading Handbooks and other ways to bypass the employment at will rule →
Employee handbook, Employment at will rule

The employment at will rule in West Virginia

Leave a comment

Part 1 of a series on West Virginia employment law

This blog article is the first part of a series I will write on employment law in West Virginia, with a focus on litigation issues relating to alleged wrongful discharge.

I will start with the employment at will rule, and will carry through with articles on the numerous exceptions to the employment at will rule.

What is the employment at will rule?

The courts have long had a love-hate relationship with the employment at will rule. West Virginia, like virtually all other states, adheres to the rule.

So, what is the employment at will rule? For convenience, I will define it in terms of the right to end or terminate the employment relationship, but more about that definition in a moment. And more below about the big qualification on the rule.

One way to state the rule is that both parties to the employment relationship, the employer and the employer, have the right to terminate the employment relationship at any time and for any reason (but not for an illegal reason, and that is discussed below). It is important to understand that those are the two essential attributes of the rule: to terminate the employment relationship (1) at any time, and (2) for any reason. Both sides (employer and employee) have that right, although the right is almost always examined in terms of the employer’s right in wrongful discharge litigation.

West Virginia’s description of the rule

In the context of termination (more about that later) the employment at will rule has been described in West Virginia this way: the rule allows an employer to terminate an employee for:

Continue reading The employment at will rule in West Virginia →